Main content

Andrew Winter

Property Expert

» Ask An Expert

General Queaton 

Hi Andrew,

I love your show.

I have an investment property in Reservoir Vic which I bought for $611K at the peak of the market in Nov 2009. It's a red clicker brick home with a terracotta roof tile with wooden double hung windows (painted white) built after the war with some art deco features. It's in orginal condition on 650 sqm of land.
I recieve net rent of $1355 pm with a loan of $645K. It's costing me around $1k pm after negative gearing and the property is not growing by the same rate.
Should I hold as it's a great home in a good area (27 Acheron Ave - google it to view photo's) or should I rennovate it to improve the return? i.e update the kitchen and bathroom or should I build a unit on the back to improve the return? I dont want to sell as I wont get my money back in this flat market, if I can afford to hold for the say next 20 yrs, do you think that the property will grow by an average of say 2% pa and is worth holdng for the long term? Or should I sell as it's costing me money to keep it and take a hit as I want to save the $1k pm? I'm 42 yrs old and have time on my side hopefully for it to grow?

Thanks , Rob

Answered Saturday 10 November 2012

I would love to help, but it is simply to complex to answer in this forum, if you really are stuck let me know via

Property Expert

Andrew Winter

Andrew believes if you haven’t sold your house within two months then you’re doing something wrong.

» More Questions & Answers

Sale of our house 

Do you want the bad news? 4 agents and a failed auction and a perfect house (unless it is perfect to you and not for the buying public?) means only one thing can be wrong, it has to be the pri... Read more

House for sale 

David sounds fascinating, I am pretty sure we are 'full' at the moment, but drop me an email and I will forward this on for you via - if you do get really stuck I c... Read more

Selling my house 

Change agents, he or she should know WHY, that is simple! So get some other agents in, suggest you take the home of the market give it a break and then you can re launch a fresh!  ... Read more

Renovate pre-sale 

Sue - really difficult to answer, good local agents can help BUT if you are not able to do some of the work yourself, or have trusted trades people and family to call in it could become a very... Read more


Zubi - do not suggest you DIY this job, it will look like you have and just make the problem even worse. Goggle 'tile spraying' in your area there are some great companies out there no... Read more

Macleay Island 

Hi Trevor, yes all info on - pretty sure it could be the 22nd November? ... Read more

Property listed on market with heads of looks no offers 

Hi Shaun - it looks like they have done a lot of work when you research it on RPData, maybe kitchen is not good and needs doing in light of everything else, but generally it looks fine - are you su... Read more

School Project 

Great question and the simple answer is 'yes'. Area for example would relate to styles and tastes, urban locations would embrace one look, whereas a family area with older homes a more trad... Read more

Recommended Tradesman to put floorboards 

I can't recommend anyone directly, but firstly ensure you are allowed to change floor coverings in your unit, especially if you have neighbours below? Secondly to keep costs down consider '... Read more

selling farm/lifestyle 

Hi Linda, as the property has no recent sales listing history on line, it is impossible for me to offer any advice, just note rural inland property is generally a slow seller, it could take months... Read more


Sign Out

Join the Conversation

Please note, LifeStyle cannot respond to all comments posted in our comments feed. If you have a comment or query you would like LifeStyle to respond to, please use our feedback form.